Behind Olema House and Due West, an eight-inch storm drain runs underground from the front parking lot, between the two buildings, and down to Olema Creek. Rainwater is all it was ever meant to carry. The Point Reyes Light reported that a previous owner had tied three smaller plastic pipes into it. They carried water from a French drain behind the hotel and ran above the septic field. One cracked, and sewage seeped in.
Olema Creek is a winter spawning stream. It joins Lagunitas Creek and then reaches the bay. National Park Service rangers found the contamination during routine creek testing, and Marin County Environmental Health Services capped the drain on October 9. On October 12 the California Department of Public Health ordered every shellfish operation in Tomales Bay to close. Greg Pirie, the county's deputy director of environmental health, told the Light there was no way for the hotel owners to have known about the leak.
One cracked pipe in Olema stopped the harvest all the way up the Marshall shore. What kept oysters on some counters that week will also decide which counters have them this December: holding tanks, and a second farm outside the bay.
Fifteen miles of creek, one bay
Hog Island Oyster Co.'s October 14 statement put the source "15 miles away at a hotel near Olema," on a tributary that feeds the southern end of Tomales Bay. The company stopped harvesting the morning the state called and put that day's harvest back in the water. It also began a voluntary, precautionary withdrawal of Tomales Bay shellfish harvested between September 14 and October 12, including its Sweetwaters and Earthquake Bays, and stressed that this was "not a recall." No illnesses were reported.
According to the Light, the samples showed no detectable viral indicators, and harvest resumed on the morning of Sunday, October 18. Gary Fleener, Hog Island's director of science and policy, told the paper he could not recall an earlier Tomales Bay closure caused by a septic leak. The familiar closures come in winter, the Light noted, when rains carry runoff into the bay.
The whole bay closed over a problem that started on one property in Olema. Our post on which septic system a Tomales Bay property relies on follows the same water from the other direction. Whatever drains across the watershed ends up where the oysters grow.
What the tanks and the second farms bought
The same closure hit each grower differently. The Press Democrat's November 10 story opened on a Monday afternoon in Marshall, Hog Island's first day back on the water, with the crew hanging seaweed-heavy nets and pushing oysters onto a wash conveyor while customers at The Boat Oyster Bar next door ate the day's catch. During the closure, Hog Island served oysters from its Humboldt Bay farm, while other growers waited for clearance.
The scale explains why the second farm matters. Hog Island employs around 300 people and may harvest 50,000 oysters in a single day, harvest manager Brendan Reed-Naughton told the paper this fall. Bodega Bay Oyster Company, whose crews the paper photographed processing Tomales Bay oysters in Marshall on November 2, also works this bay.
The holding tanks are the other cushion, and the winter of 2023 tested them. That spring the Point Reyes Light reported that Hog Island and Tomales Bay Oyster Company, the bay's two biggest operations, both had temperature-controlled tanks that could hold oysters after harvest. That year's storms kept parts of the bay closed for three or four weeks at a time. Through early April 2023, Hog Island had harvested for one week in January and six days in March. Its tanks ran out, and it ordered oysters from trusted farms in the Northwest and on the East Coast. Tomales Bay Oyster Company had enough in its tanks to ride out the March closure. Starbird Mariculture, a smaller grower without tanks, stopped its restaurant deliveries for three weeks.
"We watch the weather like hawks," Heidi Gregory, then managing Tomales Bay Oyster Company, told the Light that spring. The same story put Hog Island's typical year at about 3 million oysters and Tomales Bay Oyster Company's at around 1.6 million.
A winter the growers are bracing for
The Press Democrat's November story describes farms preparing for what may be the most powerful El Niño on record. Whitt Strain, co-manager of Bodega Bay Oyster Company, told the paper that in normal winters the industry goes at least two months without harvesting or income because of storms, and he expects this one to be worse. His crew spent the fall "securing gear for big storm events, making sure insurance is fully loaded." Fleener said farmers need plans for coming king tides and potentially unprecedented storms and floods. Martin Seiler, manager at Tomales Bay Oyster Company, named the pressures farms juggle: water temperature, freshwater runoff, salinity and sediment.
Rain can do more than pause the harvest. Growers told the Light in 2023 that storm sediment can bury oysters and that too much fresh water can kill them slowly, which is a bigger worry for the farms than a few lost days.
Buying from the bay through December
Tomales Bay Oyster Company lists fall and winter hours of 9 a.m. to 4 p.m. every day, closed on Thanksgiving and Christmas. The farm asks visitors not to picnic on site and links to a map of nearby West Marin parks instead. In mid-November its site said, "Tomales Bay Is Open for Shellfish Harvesting!" That banner is the quickest check before a drive up Highway 1, and a phone call to the farm is the surest.
The Marshall Store is also closed on Thanksgiving Day and Christmas Day and keeps its regular hours the rest of the season: 11 a.m. to 3 p.m. on weekdays and 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. on weekends. Its oysters come from its family farm, Tomales Bay Oyster Company, and the Preston Point Pacifics on its menu are that farm's. Our earlier post on the Marshall shoreline's weekly schedule covers how the rest of the shore's week runs.
Hog Island's Marshall farm, home to The Boat Oyster Bar, draws on both its Tomales Bay and Humboldt Bay farms. That second farm kept it supplied through October's closure, and Hog Island says it holds its oysters in UV-sterilized seawater for at least 24 hours before sale.
In a stormy December, then, the counters run on different supply lines. The Marshall Store and Tomales Bay Oyster Company sell from the bay and from that farm's tanks, and Hog Island can fall back on Humboldt Bay or its partner farms. If a Tomales Bay oyster is what you want on the holiday table, ask the counter where that day's oysters came from. The people working there will know.
Back in Olema, Pirie used the leak to remind people to check their septic systems "ahead of the upcoming storm season." Our post on the Olema crossroads covers the stops at that end of the watershed.
If you're planning a holiday table by the bay, or wondering how a property near the water connects to the watershed it drains into, I'm glad to talk it through. Call or text Terry Donohue for local guidance on Bolinas & West Marin homes, or for the latest on what's happening along the Marshall shore.